Pete Gorman scored on a driving layup as time expired and No. 15 seed Mater Dei shocked No. 2 Middletown South, ending the Eagles' 19-game winning streak.
James Anderson caught fire from long-range against the Mustangs, earning Turning Point Player of the Game honors and propelling Middletown South to the victory.
James Anderson hit 11 three-pointers and scored 33 points to lead a spectacular shooting display that gave Middletown South a win over Freehold Township.