Teams selected by Matt Manley based on a conglomeration of games watched, discussions with area coaches and media, coaches all-division teams, and statistics reported to Shore Sports Network.

First Team

Position Player Team Grade
Forward Eamon Kitson Rumson-Fair Haven Sr.
Forward Justin Gilson Red Bank Jr.
Forward Blake Czajkowski Central Jr.
Forward Wadneson Alexis Ocean So.
Midfield Ryan Hammer Manalapan Jr.
Midfield Jack Flanagan Holmdel Sr.
Midfield Garrett Muzikowski Jackson Memorial Sr.
Midfield Pete Martin Rumson-Fair Haven Sr.
Defense Nick Sica Toms River North Sr.
Defense Michael Jelinsky Colts Neck Sr.
Defense Brian Dolan Manalapan Sr.
Defense Brian Dziobak Freehold Township Sr.
Goalkeeper Paul Kelly Monsignor Donovan Sr.

Second Team

Position Player Team Grade
Forward Russell Romano Christian Brothers Academy Jr.
Forward Lorenzo Scala Toms River East Sr.
Forward Mike Dalton Monsignor Donovan Sr.
Forward Jason Kyriacou Holmdel Sr.
Midfield Stevenly Joseph Neptune Sr.
Midfield Georges Fiori Middletown North Sr.
Midfield Justin Silverberg Ocean Sr.
Midfield Chris Barcas Wall Sr.
Defense Dave D'Agostino Wall Sr.
Defense Tyler Roman Ocean Sr.
Defense Ryan Strang Rumson-Fair Haven Sr.
Defense Sean Suskevich Monsignor Donovan Sr.
Goalkeeper Chris Seager Ocean Sr.
Goalkeeper Jack Wishart Wall Jr.

Third Team

Position Player Team Grade
Forward Jose Cesaire Asbury Park Sr.
Forward Jason Tonelli Colts Neck Sr.
Forward Sean Moore Toms River North Sr.
Forward Brendan Barcas Wall Jr.
Midfield George Kavarakas Ocean Sr.
Midfield Josh Sommerer Toms River East Jr.
Midfield Matt Dell Rumson-Fair Haven Sr.
Midfield Doug Jensen Central Jr.
Defense Cameron Wenz Wall Sr.
Defense Connor Shields Holmdel Sr.
Defense Mike McNicholas Manalapan So.
Defense Jackson Irwin Christian Brothers Academy Sr.
Goalkeeper Tyler Marchiano Holmdel So.
Goalkeeper Chris Tierney Rumson-Fair Haven Sr.